
Last week, I received a consultation call. The caller was someone relocating to Cincinnati for work from another state, and they had one question: Should I buy now, or should I rent first?
To cut to the chase, I leaned towards renting this winter. Looking at the October numbers explains why.
First, let's talk about sale prices. According to data compiled by a local brokerage from Cincinnati MLS, the average transaction price in October was $373,492.
This is a 0.46% increase from September's $371,782, and a 0.99% increase compared to last October's $369,828. So, it has barely risen by 1% over the year.
For reference, this figure is based on the metropolitan area covered by MLS, not just the city limits of Cincinnati. There are significant differences when looking at specific neighborhoods.
The transaction volume is even more striking. In October, there were 1,607 residential transactions, which is a decrease of 5.19% from September and 9.67% from the same month last year.
The time it takes for homes to sell has also increased. The average market stay is now 29 days, longer than 28 days in September and 26 days last October.
Looking at the listings, the picture becomes clearer. According to data from Realtor.com compiled by the St. Louis Fed (FRED), there were 5,286 active listings in the Cincinnati metropolitan area in October.
This is a 21.6% increase compared to 4,346 listings last October. It has also risen from 4,868 listings in September.
On the other hand, asking prices have decreased. The median listing price in October was $340,000, down from $354,900 in June, marking four consecutive months of decline.
Interestingly, this $340,000 is the same figure as last October. The prices that rose in the spring and summer have returned to where they were a year ago.
To summarize, inventory is increasing, transactions are decreasing, and it takes longer to sell homes. For buyers, this creates a market with more room for negotiation.
But why didn't I recommend buying right away? The answer is interest rates.
According to Freddie Mac's weekly survey, as of November 5, the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate was 7.18%. It has decreased for three consecutive weeks from 7.32% on October 22.
However, it was 6.22% at the same time last year. It is still nearly a full percentage point higher.
For reference, the 15-year fixed rate for the same week was 6.57%. While shorter terms lower the interest rate, the monthly payments increase, making it a burdensome choice for families with tight cash flow.
I ran some calculations. If you buy a $340,000 home with a 20% down payment, borrowing $272,000 at 7.18%, your monthly principal and interest payment would be $1,843.
If you had taken the same loan at 6.22%, it would be $1,669. Just the difference in interest rates means you would pay over $170 more each month. This does not even include property taxes and insurance.
Now, let's look at rents. According to the November report from ApartmentList reflecting October trends, the median rent in Cincinnati is $1,082.
A one-bedroom is $925, and a two-bedroom is $1,170. The national median is $1,215 for a one-bedroom and $1,369 for a two-bedroom, so rents here are definitely on the lower side.
In October, rents decreased by 0.4%. However, on a year-over-year basis, they increased by 2.0%, which is faster than Ohio's average of 1.0% and the national average of 0.1%.
This part was honestly a bit surprising. While home prices have remained stagnant for a year, rents have been steadily rising. Still, a 2% increase is manageable.
Returning to the person who consulted with me, the difference between the two-bedroom rent of $1,170 and the loan payment of $1,843 is $673 per month.
Over a year, that adds up to over $8,000. I believe it's more realistic to save that money for a down payment right now.
Moreover, buying a home without knowing the neighborhood can be risky. You need to live through at least one season to get a feel for the school districts and commute times.
Of course, renting is not the right answer for everyone. If you plan to stay long-term and have a specific neighborhood in mind, now could be a good time for price negotiations with the current inventory.
For those individuals, it might be worth asking for seller credits or a rate buy-down. In a market where homes are sitting for 29 days, sellers are likely to be open to negotiations.
If you decide to rent, there are also things to keep in mind. Set the lease term for one year, but make sure to check the termination conditions in the contract in case you decide to buy a home in the meantime.
The two numbers I'll be watching until spring are whether interest rates drop below 7% and whether the increased inventory leads to actual price reductions.
For reference, the average sale price and transaction volume are based on secondary data compiled from local MLS, so they may differ slightly from official association announcements. Be sure to check the recent transaction history in your desired neighborhood before making any decisions.

BrightSummit70







B.I.G. Victor | 
Amber H | 
uplifted | 
Dr. Kelso | 
silents | 
timistic | 
content | 
peace | 
hopeful | 
Good Hotels |
heartwarming |
Blogging with a Heart Like the Sun |
The Bread Lover Runs on Bread |
yogurt 1 |
Macon Boy |
Joyce 77 |
The Yellow |
bluebird |
Epoca News |
Samttugi Grasshopper Noodle |
kansan55 |
Skyline |
Investment Information News Update |
diamondo |
Fairfax Fox |
kuku 100 |
US Embassy |
Kims Spring |