
Recently, a junior colleague quietly sat next to me in the church fellowship hall and shared this story. During a meeting, the team leader said, "Can you try to speak more like an American?"
This colleague has no issues working in English. There were hardly any customer complaints. However, after that comment, the opportunity for a presentation quietly shifted to someone else.
When he asked me, "Should I just tolerate this?" I couldn't answer right away. So, I went home and looked into it one by one.
To cut to the chase, disadvantages based on accent can be reported as employment discrimination depending on the situation. However, it's not a blanket rule.
Title VII of the Federal Civil Rights Act prohibits discrimination based on national origin. The EEOC explains that this protection includes accent.
So, should companies not consider accent at all? Not necessarily.
The EEOC's 2016 enforcement guidance on national origin discrimination provides clear criteria. Accent can only be considered if English verbal communication is actually necessary for the job and if the accent materially interferes with job performance.
This means that comments like "It's a bit hard to understand" or "It sounds unfamiliar" are not valid reasons. There must be evidence that it actually hindered work.
The guidance even provides examples. If a seasoned sales employee has an accent but is easy to understand, and they are told to "speak like an American," that could support a discrimination claim.
Isn't that almost identical to my junior colleague's case? I was surprised while reading it.
The requirement for English fluency is similar. The EEOC warns that uniform English requirements that exceed the necessary level for the job can be problematic.
By the way, last November, the EEOC released new information stating that discrimination against American workers is also considered national origin discrimination. It's good to know that the fundamental principle of protecting accents remains unchanged, even if government priorities shift.
Now, let's talk about practical matters. Title VII applies to workplaces with 15 or more employees.
If it's a smaller company, you'll need to find another route. The IER (Immigrant and Employee Rights Section) under the Department of Justice handles national origin discrimination for businesses with 4 to 14 employees.
Deadlines are crucial. EEOC complaints must be filed within 180 days of the discriminatory act, but in places like Texas, where state agencies enforce the same law, it extends to 300 days.
However, there's a catch. Claims under Texas state law must be filed with the Texas Workforce Commission Civil Rights Division within 180 days.
This means if you delay thinking you can just file with the EEOC within 300 days, you could lose your rights under state law. I would definitely act within 180 days.
You can start a complaint online at the EEOC Public Portal, and you can also call 1-800-669-4000 for inquiries. There is an EEOC field office in San Antonio that covers several counties in South and Central Texas, including Bexar County.
There are also things to prepare before filing. First, write down the date and location of the comment, as well as the people who were present.
If you have email or messenger records, keep them in a personal archive. You should also gather evidence that shows you have been performing well, such as performance reviews or customer feedback.
The key is to specifically connect how you faced disadvantages in promotions, assignments, or evaluations due to your accent. Just feeling upset is not enough.
It's also illegal to face retaliation for filing a complaint. If there are retaliatory actions like termination or reduced hours, that can also be reported separately.
Honestly, I'm not one to easily recommend lawsuits. I believe it's best to be recognized for your skills first, and if possible, to resolve issues through dialogue with the company.
However, if your evaluation is lowered solely due to your accent while your skills remain intact, that's not meritocracy. It undermines the principle of merit-based evaluation.
So, I advised my junior colleague to first raise the issue in writing with HR and keep a record of it. Having a trace of having followed internal procedures can be beneficial later.
Since the facts can vary by situation, I recommend consulting an employment law attorney or the EEOC before filing a complaint. Many places offer free initial consultations.
We immigrants tend to see our accents as a weakness that needs to be corrected. I did for a long time too.
However, the law clearly states that opportunities should not be taken away from capable individuals because of their accent. Sometimes patience is a virtue, but there's a difference between knowing and tolerating versus being unaware and suffering.

ThirstyJjang







neroyo | 
American Food Information & Calories | 
Bald Eagle Brothers | 
sunny side | 
kodak | 
solvix18 | 

Helpful Life Stories | 
Thoroughly Prepared Pioneer Spirit | 
Zoom Zoom Zoom |
Epoca News |
Samttugi Grasshopper Noodle |
kansan55 |
Skyline |
Investment Information News Update |
diamondo |
Fairfax Fox |
kuku 100 |
US Embassy |
Kims Spring |
TOTO Together |
Princess Park |
Respect Rooftop Bro |
Hani 1977 |
Tilt Cicy |
yorvik12 |
lollipop |
lioness |
DREAM BIG |
corner |