How Much Can You Save by Switching Kids' Christmas Gifts to Experiences? - Thousand Oaks - 1

This year, I took my child's wish list and added items to my cart one by one. Honestly, I hesitated when I saw the total right before checkout.

I chose items similar to last year, but it definitely felt more expensive this time. So, I decided to check the numbers step by step.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) consumer price data for September 2026, toy prices have risen by 6.6% compared to a year ago. The overall inflation rate for the same month was 3.7%.

It's also notable that prices increased by 4.2% in just one month from August to September. This spike right before the holiday shopping season is particularly painful.

Reports cite tariffs on Chinese products and rising costs of plastic materials and transportation as major causes. Most toys are imports, so they are directly affected by these factors.

So, how are other families handling this? Deloitte's 2026 Holiday Retail Survey provides good reference material.

This survey was conducted online with 4,000 American consumers from late August to early September. The average expected holiday spending per household is $1,654, which is a 4% increase from last year.

What's interesting is the breakdown of spending. The expected amount for purchasing goods is $988, which is a 10% increase, while spending on activities like dining out or travel is expected to be $666, a 4% decrease.

However, when it comes to gifts alone, there's a contrasting trend. The percentage of respondents planning to give experience gifts has risen to 50%, up from 47% in 2025 and 39% in 2024.

In summary, due to rising prices, the burden of purchasing goods has increased, while the method of gifting is gradually shifting towards experiences.

That said, saying "experiences are always cheaper" would be incorrect. Depending on the choice, experiences can be much more expensive than toys.

The key is to reduce the number of gifts. In the Deloitte survey, respondents planned an average of 8 gifts.

If a family typically buys several small toys for one child, changing this structure can be the most effective. Let's consider an example.

If you buy 5 toys at $40 each, that totals $200. If you remove 3 of those and replace them with one experience, the math changes.

The official website for the LA Zoo lists a family annual membership for $150. Prices may vary, so be sure to check again before purchasing.

Adding 2 toys at $80 to the $150 membership totals $230. Just looking at the numbers, it actually costs $30 more. I was briefly taken aback when I first calculated it.

However, this membership allows for multiple visits throughout the year. For families planning to go once or twice on weekends anyway, that admission fee is essentially covered.

Therefore, the savings effect of experience gifts should be evaluated based on whether it replaces the money you were already planning to spend. Missing this point can lead to a flawed calculation.

Conversely, if a family doesn't usually go out much, there's no need to invest in an annual membership. A single day pass would suffice, and that would definitely cost less than three toys.

There are also cheaper options. A semester of swimming or art classes at a local recreation center, or a day date coupon for just mom and the child, for example.

These options are not expensive but provide a "time just for me" experience for the child, which tends to be well-received. Among my acquaintances, the highest satisfaction came from these types of gifts.

Additionally, classes or date coupons have the advantage of not piling up at home. Everyone has experienced the sigh of seeing toys stuffed in a corner by January.

There are certainly opposing views. Some argue that if there's no fun in tearing open wrapping paper on Christmas morning, the child will feel disappointed.

This is a valid point. Especially for younger children, the joy of seeing a gift in front of them is significant.

So, I recommend putting a ticket or a handwritten coupon in a small box for wrapping. This way, you keep the fun of unwrapping while changing the contents.

I'll also share a research finding. A study by Cindy Chan and Cassie Mogilner published in the Journal of Consumer Research.

They analyzed actual gift exchanges and found that experience gifts foster closer relationships between the giver and receiver compared to material gifts.

Interestingly, this effect stemmed from the emotions felt during the experience rather than at the moment of receiving the gift. They noted that the effect was present even without being together.

Of course, this research isn't exclusively focused on children, so applying it directly should be done cautiously. However, the direction is certainly worth considering.

My conclusion is this: rather than switching everything to experiences, it's more realistic to reduce the number of gifts to one big gift, one experience, and a couple of small toys.

And when choosing experience gifts, make sure they fit within the schedule your family originally planned. That way, you truly save money and create lasting memories for the child.