Kahului Home Prices Drop 11% in September, Maui Market Insights for October - Kahului - 1

I opened the data to summarize the home prices in Maui for October. To get straight to the point, the official figures for October have not yet been released as of the time of writing this article.

The Maui Association of Realtors (RAM) typically releases monthly statistics in early to mid-next month. So today, we will look at the most recent confirmed figures from September and the actual interest rates that moved in October.

First, let's talk about single-family homes. The median sale price for single-family homes in Maui County in September was $1.15 million.

A year ago in September, it was $1.2925 million. That's an 11% decrease.

The number of transactions was 52, down 7.1% from last year's 56 transactions. The median time to sell was 134 days.

The median price in August was $1.2 million. In July, it was $1.15 million, so it fluctuated between $1.15 million and $1.2 million throughout the summer before dropping again in September.

For reference, the median price for single-family homes last October was $1.245 million, with 64 transactions. When the October figures are released, you can compare them to these numbers.

The condo market tells a different story. There were 72 condo transactions in September, a 56.5% increase from last year's 46 transactions.

The median price was $660,000, which is a 1.1% increase from last year. Prices are holding steady, and transactions have significantly increased.

However, the median time to sell condos was 199 days, which is 56.7% longer than last year. While many were sold, it seems that older listings were cleared out.

Why is there such a divide? In my view, two factors are at play.

One is Bill 9. This ordinance, signed by the Maui County Mayor in December 2025, gradually eliminates short-term vacation rentals in apartment-zoned areas. The Minatoya List condos are affected.

The phase-out will start in West Maui, followed by other areas. Since the dates vary slightly in different sources, if you own one of those condos, you should definitely check the original ordinance.

This ordinance has led to more listings coming onto the market, and for those looking to buy for residential purposes, it has actually widened their options. This could explain the increase in condo transactions.

The other factor is interest rates. What has changed in October is more related to this than home prices.

The average 30-year fixed mortgage rate from Freddie Mac rose to 7.4% in early October, the highest level in nearly three years.

It then began to decline, reaching 7.32% on October 22 and 7.18% in the announcement on November 5. Compared to the same time last year at 6.22%, it is still nearly a full percentage point higher.

In places like Maui, where home prices exceed a million dollars, this difference is significant. Even borrowing the same amount, the monthly interest payments noticeably increase.

It makes sense to look to interest rates as a reason for the slowdown in demand for single-family homes. Conversely, the fact that rates have been declining for several weeks may have provided some relief for transactions in late October.

So, what about rents in Kahului? To be honest, there are no official rental statistics that accurately reflect changes for the month of October.

According to private site data, Zumper estimates the average rent in Kahului at $2,500 per month as of June 2026, which is a 5% decrease from a year ago.

Apartments.com lists the average rent for a one-bedroom at $1,988 and a two-bedroom at $2,170 as of January 2026. Since each site has different methods of aggregation, you shouldn't compare the numbers directly.

The general direction is similar. Prices have not risen significantly and are either stable or have slightly decreased. However, considering the period of high demand following the fire, they are still not at a low level.

Now, let's summarize what you should actually check.

If you are looking to buy a home, be sure to check the RAM October statistics that will come out in November. The key is whether the median price for single-family homes has dropped further from September.

If you are looking at condos, first check if that building is on the Minatoya List. Depending on whether the price is based on short-term rental income or residential use, your judgment will differ significantly.

You should also ask separately about management fees and insurance costs. Listings that have been on the market for a long time often have reasons behind them. It's a good idea to get a history of how much management fees have increased over the past few years.

If you are a tenant, now is a time when there is room for negotiation. When renewing your lease, bring a few comparable listings from the neighborhood to make your case easier. From the landlord's perspective, it's better to make some concessions than to have a long vacancy.

Personally, I would wait to see if single-family home rates drop below 7% before making a move. For condos, I think it's better to slowly choose from the current listings that are suitable for residential use.

Once the official October figures are released, I will revisit whether this trend was accurate. The reference data is from RAM's monthly statistics and Freddie Mac's weekly mortgage rate survey.