Delaware Ambetter Withdrawal: Highmark or AmeriHealth in 2027? - Newark - 1

If you were using the Ambetter plan through Obamacare in Delaware, you've probably received a notice from your insurance company in the mail recently. The message is simple: starting in 2027, you will no longer be able to use Ambetter on the marketplace.

Ambetter Health of Delaware will withdraw its marketplace products as of December 31, 2026. This means you will need to switch to another insurance company starting January 1.

Let's clarify a potentially confusing point. This withdrawal only applies to individual and family plans on the marketplace. Medicaid Delaware First Health, Medicare Wellcare, and Dual Align plans, which are part of the same company, will remain available.

So what are your remaining options? In the Delaware marketplace for 2027, there are only two insurance companies offering plans: Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield and AmeriHealth Caritas.

In fact, this isn't the first time this has happened. Aetna also exited the Delaware marketplace at the end of 2025. This means that for two consecutive years, one insurance company has dropped out, which is honestly a bit disheartening.

Looking at the numbers makes it even more real. According to the final approved rates announced by the state insurance department on September 4, Highmark initially requested a 20.20% increase but was approved for an average of 17.20%.

AmeriHealth Caritas received a final average increase of 13.94%. The insurance department explained that adjustments were made based on actuarial reviews and federal court rulings.

One important point to note: these percentages are based on the rates before subsidies are applied. The actual amount you pay each month will vary significantly based on the premium tax credit you receive, which depends on your income and household size.

However, there are variables regarding those subsidies as well. The insurance department cited the expiration of enhanced subsidies, federal budget actions, and rising local healthcare costs as reasons for this increase.

This aspect can be interpreted politically. One side argues that the enhanced subsidies were originally a temporary measure and that the financial burden was significant, while the other side criticizes that it suddenly increased the burden on middle-class enrollees.

I see merit in both arguments. However, from the enrollees' perspective, what matters most is not whose fault it is, but how much their bills will be.

Let's look at the plan offerings from the two insurance companies. Highmark will offer 16 standard plans and 1 catastrophic plan on the marketplace. There are HSA-linked options, and you can see vision and adult dental coverage together.

AmeriHealth Caritas will have 9 plans and emphasizes that no referral is needed to see specialists. While the number of options is fewer, the rate increases are generally lower.

So how do you choose? As I advised a friend who was using Ambetter, don't look at the premium numbers first; check the network first.

Make sure your current primary care doctor, frequently visited hospital, and your child's pediatrician are included in the new insurance company's network. If you save a few dollars on premiums but your regular doctor is out-of-network, that could end up being much more expensive.

The second consideration is medications. If you take any regular medications, be sure to check whether they are included in each plan's formulary, which is the list of covered drugs, and what tier they fall under.

If you find yourself needing to switch medications, don't make that decision alone; consult with your doctor or pharmacist. Sometimes, even if the ingredients are the same, you may need to adjust prescriptions due to insurance coverage.

The third consideration is calculating total costs. It's easy to fall into the trap of only comparing monthly premiums. You need to consider deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, and copays for visits to get a true comparison over the course of a year.

If you rarely visit the doctor, a plan with lower premiums and a higher deductible might be advantageous. Conversely, if you regularly need care or tests, a plan with slightly higher premiums but lower out-of-pocket costs may ultimately save you more.

Now, let's talk about dates. Open enrollment for 2027 started on November 1, 2026, and will continue until January 15, 2027, according to data released by CMS at the end of October.

However, a crucial date for Ambetter enrollees is December 15. You must enroll in a new plan by this date for coverage to begin without a gap on January 1.

If you wait until January 15, you can enroll, but there may be a period without insurance in between. If you need to visit a doctor early in the year, that could pose a risk.

It's not advisable to just wait and assume you'll be automatically transferred somewhere. Choosing your insurance yourself is the most reliable option.

Enrollment is done through HealthCare.gov in Delaware. You can also find information on the state government's site, choosehealthde.com.

When applying, be sure to enter your expected income for 2027 as accurately as possible. If you underestimate your income, you may have to pay back some of the subsidies when you file your taxes later.

To summarize: Ambetter will end at the end of the year, leaving Highmark and AmeriHealth Caritas as the remaining options.

Check the networks and medications first. Compare based on total costs for the year. And enroll before December 15.

If I were choosing, I would simulate the lower increase option first if both my doctors are in-network, and if one is only in one network, I would go with that one without hesitation. Ultimately, inputting data and running the numbers is the way to go.