When Should You Hire Your First Employee After Starting a Business, According to U.S. Standards? - Columbus - 1

A friend of mine started a small online boutique, and for the first few months, he managed to get by on his own.

But as orders increased to ten or twenty a day, he found that packing, shipping, and responding to inquiries made the day just disappear.

Eventually, he thought, "If this keeps up, I might burn out," so he decided to hire his first employee, but he wasn't sure when the right time to do that was.

He mentioned that there were a few days when he missed shipping deadlines while organizing packing boxes, and the delays in responses were evident in customer reviews.

In fact, 81.9% of people running businesses in the U.S. work alone without employees.

This means that only about 18.1% of businesses have employees, indicating that many people are managing both the owner and employee roles.

So, hiring that first employee is a significant decision and shouldn't be taken lightly.

One commonly mentioned guideline is to hire when your revenue consistently reaches three to four times the salary of the employee you want to hire.

The reason it's three to four times, rather than just one or two times, is that there are additional costs like taxes and insurance, and revenue can fluctuate month to month, so you need to account for a buffer to keep the business stable.

There are also signals you can pick up on beyond just numbers.

If you find yourself frequently turning away new customers or projects, that's the first signal.

When you're handling everything alone, the response time slows down, and the quality of service declines, which is another signal.

If both of these signs start to appear, the timing is likely already getting late.

Even when you start the hiring process, it doesn't mean you'll find someone right away; posting a job, interviewing, and making a decision usually takes about a month.

Moreover, it can take nearly six months for a new hire to fully adapt to the job and start generating their share of revenue, so it's wise to allow for some extra time.

However, when you actually start looking to hire, you'll find that there are more steps involved than you might expect, which can catch many people off guard.

First, you need to obtain an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS by filling out Form SS-4.

Next, you must register with the unemployment insurance agency in the state where your business is located to avoid future issues.

It's also essential to verify that the new hire is legally eligible to work in the U.S. using the I-9 form.

Additionally, under federal law, you are required to report the information of newly hired employees to the state agency within 20 days of hiring.

Since requirements can vary by state, some places like Alabama have a shorter deadline of 7 days, so it's important to check the regulations specific to your business's state.

Workers' compensation insurance is mandatory in almost every state, with Texas being one of the few exceptions.

As a note, these regulations increase as the number of employees grows; anti-discrimination laws like Title VII and the ADA apply when you have 15 or more employees, and age discrimination laws apply when you have 20 or more.

While this discussion is about hiring that first employee, it's good to be aware that as your business grows, you'll need to keep these regulations in mind.

To talk more about taxes, employers must also contribute 7.65% for Social Security and Medicare from employee wages.

Additionally, federal unemployment tax applies, with a basic rate of 6%, but if you have paid state unemployment tax, you can receive a credit that lowers the effective rate to 0.6%.

When you factor in all the benefits, you can expect an additional 20 to 30% on top of the salary.

I've heard stories of business owners who calculated only the hourly or monthly wage and were shocked when they received the tax bill.

Moreover, statistics from the U.S. Department of Labor indicate that the cost of hiring the wrong employee can be about 30% of that person's first-year salary, which adds another reason to be cautious in your hiring process.

Therefore, rather than committing to a full-time position right away, it can be a good strategy to start with part-time or contract work to see if it's a good fit.

However, just labeling someone as a contractor on paper doesn't automatically make them a contractor; the IRS assesses whether the work arrangement is truly that of an employee or contractor.

If you misclassify someone, you could end up owing back taxes and penalties, so if you go the contractor route, it's best to be clear about that.

If direct hiring feels overwhelming, you can also consider using a temp agency or freelancer platforms to hire only for the hours you need, so you can choose what works best for your situation.

On the flip side, if you hold out too long on hiring and continue to lose customers, that could lead to even greater losses.

Ultimately, it's safest to evaluate both the revenue multiplier and the moment you start turning away customers together.

If it were me, I would probably opt to hire a contractor to work together first before jumping straight into hiring a full-time employee as soon as the numbers meet the criteria.

If you ever start a business, have you thought about what criteria you would use to hire your first employee?