Pennie 2027 Premiums Average 16% Increase, Be Sure to Compare Before Renewing - Blue Bell - 1

Last week, I received a renewal notice from Pennie for 2027. I opened it and double-checked the numbers.

This time, I didn't rely on intuition; I dug into the main insurance department's announcement materials. To cut to the chase, this year's open enrollment is a year you don't want to miss out on.

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department (PID) confirmed the 2027 ACA premiums on September 18. The average increase for individual plans is 15.97%.

Small business group plans will see an average increase of 10.28%. The initial figures requested by insurers were 17.14% for individuals and 11.49% for groups.

The insurance department stated that they cut $94.7 million from the requested increases that they deemed unjustified. While this means the increases are somewhat lower, it's uncertain how much of a difference it will make.

Looking at the averages can be misleading. The approved increase rates for 14 individual market insurers range widely from Oscar at 1.4% to Ambetter at 35.1%.

Keystone Health Plan Central received an approval of 33.4%, while Highmark Benefits Group was approved for 19.7%. This means that even within the same state, the results can vary significantly depending on which company's plan you choose.

Keystone Health Plan East, which is commonly seen in the southeastern region, received a higher approval of 16.0% than requested. QCC Insurance Company also requested 19.9% but was approved for 21.3%.

It was surprising to see instances where the increases were higher than requested. The insurance department cited worsening trends in medical and prescription drug costs as the reason.

The insurance department identified three main factors for the increases. The first is the rising costs of medical care and prescription drugs.

In fact, the claims paid by insurers in 2025 increased by $845 million, or 13%, compared to 2024. Given these numbers, it's hard to blame insurers alone.

The second factor is the expiration of the enhanced premium tax credit. The federal subsidies that increased during the pandemic will end on December 31, 2025, and Congress has not extended them.

The third factor is the federal budget law (H.R. 1) passed in July 2025. With the addition of Medicaid work requirements and paperwork, the insurance department expects the number of uninsured individuals to rise in 2027.

As subsidies decrease, some enrollees will drop out, and if the remaining pool consists mainly of sicker individuals, premiums will rise again. This is a classic case of adverse selection.

So, will the state government step in? The insurance department's announcement did not mention any new state-level subsidies.

The announcement states that Pennie is the only place that can receive financial support to lower premiums and out-of-pocket costs. Ultimately, what you get is the existing federal premium tax credit, and the governor has indicated that it's difficult to fill the federal gap with just the state budget.

Honestly, I understand this part. If the state were to cover the money taken away by the federal government every year, it would ultimately be a burden on other taxpayers, and it's not a sustainable structure.

However, this makes it clear what individuals need to do. The 2027 open enrollment period is from November 1 to January 15, 2027.

To receive coverage starting January 1, you must enroll by December 15. Be sure to mark this date on your calendar.

There's also a reason not to rely solely on automatic renewal. Even if you have the same plan, the premiums may have changed significantly, and another company's plan might be much cheaper.

Additionally, due to H.R. 1, automatic renewal will no longer exist. Starting with the 2028 coverage, you will need to verify your information each year, or you won't be renewed.

Changes based on immigration status also need to be considered. Starting January 1, 2027, federal subsidies and cost-sharing reductions will be limited to lawful permanent residents, entrants from Cuba and Haiti, and COFA migrants.

Refugees and asylum seekers will lose their subsidy eligibility and can only enroll at full price. Pennie estimates that around 20,000 to 30,000 people will lose eligibility this way.

It's also wise to estimate income conservatively. Subsidies are calculated based on expected income, and if actual income is higher, you'll have to pay it back during tax filing, and the federal amendments have increased the repayment burden.

This is the order I plan to follow. First, I will update my income information with Pennie. Then, I will compare the monthly premiums and deductibles of plans with the same metal tier across different insurers in a table.

Finally, I will check whether my current hospital and medications are included in the new plan's network and formulary. Even if the premium is lower, if the medications I use are excluded, it could end up being a loss.

If you are taking any medications, it's safe to consult with your doctor or pharmacist about alternative medications or coverage before changing plans.

There's no need to be alarmed by the average increase of 15.97%, but if you do nothing, you might end up paying more than that average. I plan to compare options directly this year and switch plans if necessary.