Alabama 2027 Obamacare Premium Increase of Over 20%, Oscar at 33.8% Highest - Birmingham - 1

Last week, while having coffee in the church fellowship hall, one of the deacons who runs a small business showed me a renewal notice. He was wondering if the premium increase for next year was correct.

I was momentarily speechless when I saw the numbers. So, I looked up the data from the Alabama Department of Insurance (ALDOI) myself. Today, I will summarize that information step by step.

The Alabama Department of Insurance announced in early September that it had approved the individual health insurance rates for 2027. The new rates will take effect on January 1, 2027.

Let's start with the average increase rates by company. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama is at 19.9%, and UnitedHealthcare is at 27.5%.

The lowest increase was from Celtic, sold under the Ambetter brand, at 11.4%. Meanwhile, Oscar had the highest increase at 33.8%.

The 34% mentioned in the news title refers to this 33.8%. It rounds up to the correct number.

So, what is the average for the entire state? You need to be a bit cautious here.

The announcement from the Department of Insurance does not provide a weighted average reflecting the number of enrollees. It only has the average by company.

As a result, different private analysis sites have varying calculations. ACASignups estimates it at 20.7%, while healthinsurance.org estimates it at around 25%.

Healthinsurance.org has stated that it based its calculations on assumptions about the number of enrollees from some companies. Therefore, it would be misleading to take the 25% as an official figure. I simply understand it as an average increase in the 20% range.

More importantly, even within the same company, the increase can vary significantly by plan. You shouldn't feel reassured just by looking at the company average.

For example, Oscar's Silver Classic Standard plan increased by 38.3%, while the Gold Classic Standard increased by 41.4%. In contrast, the Bronze Classic Standard only increased by 12.1%.

Blue Cross also shows variation; the Blue Value Gold plan increased by 25.6%, but the Blue Protect plan actually decreased by 2.3%. So, it's best to check the name of the plan you are enrolled in for accuracy.

Why did the rates increase so much? Insurance companies cite rising medical costs and prescription drug prices as the main reasons. Changes in subsidies also play a significant role.

The enhanced premium tax credit, which increased during COVID, will end by the end of 2025. As a result, households exceeding 400% of the federal poverty line will no longer receive subsidies.

This issue is divisive. One side argues that continuously covering premiums with tax dollars is not sustainable. The other side worries that small business owners in the middle class will be the first to feel the impact.

I believe both sides have valid points. However, it seems clear that families like ours, with incomes that fall into a gray area, will feel the effects the most.

For reference, the above increase rates are based on the original prices before applying subsidies. If you receive subsidies, the actual amount you pay may differ.

So, what should you do now? Start by marking your calendar.

According to the CMS announcement, the open enrollment for 2027 insurance will begin on November 1, 2026, and end on January 15, 2027. However, to have coverage starting on January 1, you must enroll by December 15.

If you do nothing, most plans will automatically renew. While this is convenient, I want to emphasize that you should not just let it go this year.

First, visit HealthCare.gov and re-enter your expected income for 2027. The amount of your subsidy could change immediately.

Second, compare plans of the same tier side by side by company. Since four companies will continue to sell next year in Alabama, you have options.

Third, before changing plans, check if your hospital and doctor are in the network. Saving a few dozen dollars on premiums could lead to losing your primary care physician, which would be a bigger loss.

If you are taking any medications, you should also check if they are included in the new plan's formulary. Make sure to discuss this with your doctor or pharmacist before making a decision.

If you find English documents overwhelming, you can use navigator counseling services that offer free assistance. You can find nearby counseling centers on HealthCare.gov.

You can view detailed rate information by company and plan on the Alabama Department of Insurance website. I also compared the tables there one by one.

That deacon ultimately decided to switch to a different silver plan from the same company. There was a plan with a much smaller increase.

My conclusion is simple. This year, make sure to compare and choose instead of just relying on automatic renewal. Circle December 15 on your calendar.