Understanding the Differences Between OTC and Prescription Hearing Aids This Black Friday - Orlando - 1

These days, my inbox fills up with Black Friday ads, often several a day. One that stands out is the discounts on hearing aids. I've seen ads offering 30% off on pairs that cost several hundred dollars.

A friend of mine saw this and asked me what the difference is between these and the ones that cost thousands at the hospital. The question is short, but the answer is longer than expected, so I thought I'd break it down today.

First, let's clarify what OTC, or over-the-counter, hearing aids are. The FDA created this category in August 2022, and it went into effect on October 17 of the same year.

It's aimed at adults aged 18 and older who perceive they have mild to moderate hearing loss. In English, we refer to this as perceived mild to moderate hearing loss.

In this case, you can buy them online or in stores without a doctor's visit, prescription, or fitting by an audiologist. It's like choosing reading glasses off the pharmacy shelf.

On the other hand, prescription hearing aids are products that do not fall under the OTC criteria. Devices for severe hearing loss or those used by individuals under 18 are classified as prescription.

So how much is the price difference? According to a 2025 consumer survey by the hearing aid publication HearingTracker, the average cost for a pair of OTC hearing aids was $502. The range was quite broad, from $20 to $2,000.

For prescription hearing aids, the average cost was $3,432, with a range from $1,000 to $8,500. On average, that's nearly a sevenfold difference. I was honestly a bit surprised when I first saw these numbers.

However, it's misleading to view this difference as just the cost of the devices. The price of prescription aids typically includes services like hearing tests, custom fittings, and follow-up visits for adjustments.

With OTC, you handle that process yourself. You adjust the sound using an app, and if it doesn't work, you readjust it, and if it still doesn't work, you return it. You save money by doing the work yourself.

There's one important thing to check. The FDA requires that OTC hearing aid boxes include a warning about when to see a doctor.

If you suddenly experience hearing loss, if one ear is particularly unresponsive, if you have pain or discharge from your ear, or if you experience dizziness, then you shouldn't start with OTC. In such cases, you should see an ENT specialist first.

Legally, adults are not prevented from purchasing without a consultation. However, if the cause is earwax blockage or a treatable condition, the cost of the hearing aids becomes a sunk cost.

Next, let's talk about insurance. This is a common misconception among those approaching retirement.

Original Medicare, which includes Part A and B, does not cover the hearing aids themselves or the tests needed to fit them. However, diagnostic tests ordered by a doctor to check for medical issues may be covered.

Many Medicare Advantage plans include separate hearing benefits. The issue is that limits and conditions vary by plan. Some cover the full amount, while others only provide a set amount.

So, before comparing prices this Black Friday, I recommend checking your plan's Summary of Benefits. Many times, benefits only apply if you purchase from designated providers, so you could miss out on benefits if you buy at a discount elsewhere.

If you live in Florida, there's one more regulation to be aware of. State law allows you to cancel the purchase of prescription hearing aids within 30 days if you are not satisfied.

However, the seller can retain the cost of ear molds and fitting services. According to state regulations, this can be up to $300 for one side and up to $600 for both sides. You should be aware that it's not a full refund.

Returns for OTC hearing aids follow the policies of each seller, not the law. The timeframes and conditions vary, so be sure to check the return policy before hitting the purchase button.

Hearing aids are considered medical expenses by the IRS, so they can often be purchased using HSA or FSA cards. If you have a balance left in your FSA at the end of the year, it's worth considering.

So, what would I do? First, before getting tempted by discounts, I would get a basic hearing test. Confirming whether my hearing loss is truly mild to moderate is the starting point.

If the results indicate mild or moderate loss and there are no warning symptoms, I would buy OTC from a place with a generous return period and try them out myself. It's a way to test for a few hundred dollars before spending thousands.

Conversely, if I have severe hearing loss or a significant difference between ears, I would go for prescription aids without hesitation. This isn't a matter of cost-effectiveness; it's about choosing the right tool.

Insurance benefits, tax treatment, and health status vary by individual, so it's safest to consult a professional. The same device can be the right choice for one person and a waste of money for another.

Black Friday comes around every year, but once you lose your hearing, it's hard to get it back. I believe that prioritizing the condition of your ears over discount rates is ultimately the most cost-effective choice.