When observing the Rochester school district for a long time, I often receive similar inquiries. People tend to choose between Brighton and Pittsford based solely on test scores. In the past, we would start discussions with just the numbers on the score sheet. However, now I guide them through a different order of considerations.

Brighton High School received a GreatSchools score of 8 and is classified as above the New York state average. Its attendance rate is 85%, which is higher than the state average of 73%, and it also received the College Success Award for the 2023-24 school year. Pittsford school district is rated between 9 and 10. While the numbers suggest that Pittsford is ahead, there are more factors to consider in order.

There are three main factors to check. First, how the ratings were determined. The GreatSchools score is calculated by comparing test scores, college readiness, and equity against the state average. College readiness is a measure that looks at SAT/ACT scores, AP completion rates, and graduation rates, while equity examines the performance gap among student groups. Second, the trend of ratings over the past few years. Judging based on just one year's score can lead to misinterpretation of temporary fluctuations as differences in ability. Third, the student-to-teacher ratio and actual parent reviews. Additionally, it's worth noting that elementary and middle school ratings include a separate category for Academic Growth, which measures how much students' scores have improved compared to the previous year. Even if the test scores themselves are average, a high growth rate can lead to better-than-expected ratings.

In the past, Brighton school district was the first to be mentioned among the suburbs of Rochester. Now, districts like Pittsford and Irondequoit have risen to similar levels, increasing the options available. School district rankings can change over time, so it's better to verify the current ratings and trends rather than relying on memories from a few years ago to define a specific district.

Previously, obtaining information about school districts required calling the schools directly or relying on word of mouth from local residents. Now, real estate websites allow for quick verification with just one number, but this has also led to more conclusions being drawn based solely on that one number. Both Brighton and Pittsford have received consistently good evaluations over the years, but the difference in their scores does not necessarily correlate with the quality of instruction.

For families moving to Rochester from out of state, there is one more thing to check: property taxes. Areas with high school district ratings often have higher property taxes as well. I've seen many cases where families budgeted based on the property tax rates of their previous state, only to find that their actual burden was much higher. The suburbs of Rochester show significant variations in property tax rates depending on the school district. A school district score that is 1-2 points lower does not automatically mean that the property is undervalued. There are cases where lower scores are associated with relatively lower tax burdens, so both factors need to be considered to accurately gauge the monthly expenses. Both Brighton and Pittsford have maintained stable ratings without significant fluctuations in recent years. Such long-term stability in a school district can present a more reassuring option for families purchasing a home in the U.S. for the first time. From my perspective, this consistency often has a greater impact on actual living satisfaction than just one score.

Finally, the most important verification step is to directly check the assigned school for the house you intend to purchase on the school district's website. School district boundaries can change over time, so relying solely on real estate website displays is not sufficient for confirmation.

This article is not investment or legal advice, and property taxes and school district boundaries can vary by area, so please consult with a professional before finalizing any contracts.